“Trial Court has no authority to question High Court Order”: Bombay High Court pulls up trial court for not releasing accused on bail despite High Court order.

The court of first instance does not have the power to contest an order issued by the High Court. The High Court of Bombay these days found pulling up a tribulation courtroom docket in Maharashtra for refusing to launch the applicant on bail regardless of explicit guidelines to that impact with the aid of using the HC (Gulfasha @ Alisha Mehraj Shaikh v. State of Maharashtra).

HC of Bombay Judge Sarang Kotwal discovered on June 18, 2021 that the plaintiff Gulfasha Sheikh and her 10-month-old child had been detained since November 2020, and she was subsequently released on bail.

In spite of this order, attorney Aniket Vagal turned to Judge Kotwal on June 28, 2021 on behalf of the applicant to request an urgent hearing after the court of first instance refused to accept a cash deposit and failed to release the applicant.He argued that the court of first instance refused to release the applicant because the HC did not file section 302 (murder) of the Indian Penal Code which became one of the costs towards the applicant in its order.

Terming it a “serious bench of order”, Justice Kotwal emphasized that the trial courtroom docket turned into anticipated observing the clean guidelines issued with inside the operative a part of his order. Justice Kotwal said, the subject of the judgment is absolutely unambiguous, and the court is obliged to obey the judgment. However, the implementation of this decision has created unnecessary obstacles. The superior can also change the decision, but the court of first instance has no right to object to this decision. In any case, the subject of the decision is very clear and there is no absolute ambiguity.

In order to avoid creating more obstacles, the HC added sec 302 to its previous judgment, thereby completing the judgment. The court also asked the court of first instance to pass the report to clarify its position, which will be sent to the court within 10 days.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *